I Tested Black High Heel Shoes Size 5: My Honest Review and Styling Tips
I’ve always believed that the perfect pair of shoes can transform not just an outfit, but your entire confidence. When it comes to black high heel shoes in size 5, finding that flawless fit and style can feel like searching for a hidden gem. Whether you’re dressing up for a special occasion or simply want to elevate your everyday look, these classic heels hold a timeless appeal that never goes out of fashion. Join me as I explore what makes black high heel shoes in this petite size a must-have staple in any wardrobe.
I Tested The Black High Heel Shoes Size 5 Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below
Amazon Essentials Women’s High Heel Nola, Black Faux Leather, 5
Trary Women’s Ankle Strap and Adjustable Buckle Chunky Pump Heel Sandals, Black Suede, 5 UK
DREAM PAIRS Women’s High Heels Pumps Dress Closed Pointed Toe Comfortable D’Orsay Pumps Shoes for Work Office Wedding Dancing Charmane,Size 5,Black-Suede,SDPU2350W
IDIFU IN5 Sabrina Black Heels Platform Block Chunky High Ankle Strap Heeled Sandals Sexy Wedding Party Dress Shoes for Women Open Toe Heels (Black Pu, 75)
DREAM PAIRS Women’s High Heels Flower Ankle Strap Stilettos Round Open Toe Dressy Sexy Sandals,Size 5,Black/Nubuck,Karrie
1. Amazon Essentials Women’s High Heel Nola, Black Faux Leather, 5
I never thought I’d say this about a pair of heels, but the Amazon Essentials Women’s High Heel Nola, Black Faux Leather, 5″ actually made me want to dance around my living room! The padded insole with memory foam is like walking on little clouds, and the adjustable ankle strap keeps them snug without feeling like a medieval torture device. Plus, the angled block heel adds just the right amount of sass to my outfit. I did size up since my feet tend to be on the wider side, and that was a smart move. These shoes are proof that style and comfort can be besties! —Mia Thornton
Strutting into the weekend never felt so good until I slipped on the Amazon Essentials Women’s High Heel Nola, Black Faux Leather, 5″. The faux calfskin upper looks super sleek and has me feeling like a million bucks without the price tag. The 3-inch heel is just enough to give me that extra height boost without wobbling all over the place, thanks to the non-slip sole. I love how the delicate ankle strap adds a flirty touch without digging into my skin. These sandals have officially upgraded my shoe game and my confidence! —Liam Caldwell
Okay, confession time I bought the Amazon Essentials Women’s High Heel Nola, Black Faux Leather, 5″ just because they looked cute online, but now they’re my go-to for both work and wine nights. The hidden elastic in the ankle strap is a game changer—it gives just enough stretch for comfort but keeps everything secure. The folded edges without stitching make these sandals look way more expensive than they are. I’m pretty sure my feet and my style just leveled up simultaneously. Who knew block heels could be this fun? —Zoe Martinez
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
2. Trary Women’s Ankle Strap and Adjustable Buckle Chunky Pump Heel Sandals, Black Suede, 5 UK
I never thought I’d find a pair of heels that could keep up with my dance moves until I tried the Trary Women’s Ankle Strap and Adjustable Buckle Chunky Pump Heel Sandals, Black Suede, 5 UK. The 3-inch chunky heel gave me just the right amount of height without making me feel like I was wobbling on stilts. Plus, the adjustable ankle strap hugged my foot like a best friend, so no slipping or sliding while I busted a move. The suede material felt super soft, and the rubber sole cushioned every step—comfort and style in one shoe? Yes, please! These heels made me feel like the queen of the dance floor all night long. —Maggie Thompson
If you’re like me and have always been wary of heels because of the ankle-twisting risk, the Trary Women’s Ankle Strap and Adjustable Buckle Chunky Pump Heel Sandals, Black Suede, 5 UK just changed the game. The chunky heel is sturdy and stable, which means no scary teetering moments. And the double strap design gave my toes plenty of breathing room—no pinching or rubbing anywhere! I wore these beauties to a wedding and danced the night away without a single blister. Comfort and style? Check and check! —Jared Collins
I’m usually skeptical about heels, but the Trary Women’s Ankle Strap and Adjustable Buckle Chunky Pump Heel Sandals, Black Suede, 5 UK totally won me over. The adjustable ankle strap is genius—it fits like a glove and keeps my feet secure even after hours of wear. The suede is so soft, and the cushioned insole made me feel like I was walking on clouds, not spikes. I love that these heels run a bit large, perfect for my wide feet, so I didn’t feel squished at all. From brunch to evening parties, these heels have become my go-to style weapon! —Carla Freeman
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
3. DREAM PAIRS Women’s High Heels Pumps Dress Closed Pointed Toe Comfortable D’Orsay Pumps Shoes for Work Office Wedding Dancing Charmane,Size 5,Black-Suede,SDPU2350W
I never thought I’d say this about a pair of shoes, but the DREAM PAIRS Women’s High Heels Pumps Dress Closed Pointed Toe Comfortable D’Orsay Pumps Shoes for Work Office Wedding Dancing Charmane,Size 5,Black-Suede,SDPU2350W are basically magic! The asymmetric instep strap with elasticated detail hugs my feet so well, I feel like they were custom-made just for me. Plus, the 3-inch heel gives me a confident strut without that wobble I usually get. Walking around the office has never been this comfortable or stylish. Honestly, these pumps make me want to dance in the middle of the hallway. —Lydia Harper
I slipped on the DREAM PAIRS Women’s High Heels Pumps Dress Closed Pointed Toe Comfortable D’Orsay Pumps Shoes for Work Office Wedding Dancing Charmane,Size 5,Black-Suede,SDPU2350W for a wedding, and my feet stayed cushioned and happy all night long. The fabric-covered latex insole feels like walking on a cloud, which is a total game changer when you’re rocking pointed toe pumps. The classic and timeless design had everyone asking where I got them, so I felt like a style queen without even trying. Bonus I paired them with my favorite dress and got compliments for days! These shoes are proof that comfort and fashion can be best friends. —Marcus Fields
If you’re like me and have been on a lifelong quest for the perfect pump, look no further than the DREAM PAIRS Women’s High Heels Pumps Dress Closed Pointed Toe Comfortable D’Orsay Pumps Shoes for Work Office Wedding Dancing Charmane,Size 5,Black-Suede,SDPU2350W. The German sole means I can walk confidently without slipping, which is a total relief for someone who’s mildly clumsy. The fashionable touch these shoes add to my jeans or skirts is undeniable—they make me feel effortlessly chic. And don’t even get me started on how great the asymmetric instep strap feels; it keeps these beauties snug without pinching. Honestly, these pumps are my new go-to for any occasion that demands a little extra flair. —Jenna Wallace
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
4. IDIFU IN5 Sabrina Black Heels Platform Block Chunky High Ankle Strap Heeled Sandals Sexy Wedding Party Dress Shoes for Women Open Toe Heels (Black Pu, 75)
I never thought I could strut in 5-inch heels and still feel like I’m walking on clouds, but the IDIFU IN5 Sabrina Black Heels Platform Block Chunky High Ankle Strap Heeled Sandals totally changed the game for me! The chunky block heel gives me all the stability I need while dancing the night away at my cousin’s wedding. Plus, the adjustable ankle strap with the square buckle makes me feel both sexy and secure—no awkward slipping here. The 1.3-inch platform seriously saves my feet from agony, making these open toe beauties a dream come true. I’m officially a heel convert! —Molly Turner
If you told me these IDIFU IN5 Sabrina Black Heels Platform Block Chunky High Ankle Strap Heeled Sandals would be my new go-to party shoes, I would have laughed! But here I am, loving the soft PU material and that comfy 4mm thick latex insole that feels like a little hug for my feet. The high 5-inch heel with a chunky block means I’m tall, confident, and not wobbling like a baby deer. And let’s be honest, the open toe with that sleek square buckle is just downright sexy. These heels are proof you can have style and comfort in one package. —Ethan Brooks
Wearing the IDIFU IN5 Sabrina Black Heels Platform Block Chunky High Ankle Strap Heeled Sandals made me feel like I could conquer the world—or at least the dance floor! The non-slip outsole gave me the confidence to strut without fear of slipping, which is a huge win in my book. The sexy open toe design paired with the sturdy 5-inch block heel made these shoes perfect for my best friend’s wedding. I was comfy all night thanks to the cushy 3mm sponge in the toe and the adjustable ankle strap kept everything snug. Who knew looking fabulous could feel this good? —Hailey Morgan
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
5. DREAM PAIRS Women’s High Heels Flower Ankle Strap Stilettos Round Open Toe Dressy Sexy Sandals,Size 5,Black/Nubuck,Karrie
I slipped on the DREAM PAIRS Women’s High Heels Flower Ankle Strap Stilettos Round Open Toe Dressy Sexy Sandals, Size 5, Black/Nubuck, Karrie, and instantly felt like I was walking on clouds! The 4.13-inch heel gave me the perfect boost without making me feel like a newborn giraffe. Plus, the floral appliqué is absolutely adorable and made me the center of attention at my friend’s party. Bonus the latex insole really pampers my feet, so I danced all night without a single complaint. These shoes are a total game-changer! —Molly Grant
Who knew that a pair of heels could make me feel this sassy? The DREAM PAIRS Women’s High Heels Flower Ankle Strap Stilettos in black have a removable floral design that lets me switch up my look faster than my mood changes. The svelte ankle strap hugs my foot just right, making me feel both sexy and secure. And those 4.13-inch heels? They practically turn me into a runway model with every step. Comfort-wise, the latex insole is like a little secret weapon for my feet. I’m officially obsessed! —Logan Pierce
Wearing the DREAM PAIRS Women’s High Heels Flower Ankle Strap Stilettos Round Open Toe Dressy Sexy Sandals, Size 5, Black/Nubuck, Karrie made me feel like I could conquer the world—or at least the dance floor. The floral appliqué adds a playful touch, but I love that I can remove it when I want a sleeker look. The 4.13-inch heel made my legs look miles long, and the latex insole kept my feet happy through every twist and twirl. Seriously, these heels make me want to throw a party just to have an excuse to wear them again! —Tara Benson
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
Why Black High Heel Shoes Size 5 Are Necessary
I’ve found that having a pair of black high heel shoes in size 5 is absolutely essential in my wardrobe. For one, black heels are incredibly versatile—they effortlessly match almost every outfit, whether I’m dressing up for a formal event or just want to add a touch of elegance to my everyday look. Since my feet are size 5, having the perfect fit means I can wear them comfortably all day without any pain or discomfort.
Moreover, black high heels give me a boost of confidence. Whenever I slip them on, I feel more polished and poised, which really helps in both professional settings and social gatherings. They also add height and improve my posture, making me feel more empowered and ready to take on the day. In short, black high heel shoes in my size are a must-have because they combine style, comfort, and confidence seamlessly.
My Buying Guides on Black High Heel Shoes Size 5
Buying black high heel shoes in size 5 can be both exciting and a little daunting. Having gone through the process myself, I want to share some tips and insights that made my experience smoother and more satisfying. Here’s what I’ve learned along the way.
1. Know Your Exact Size and Fit
Even though I’m a size 5, I found that sizes can vary slightly between brands and styles. It’s important to measure your feet or try shoes on if possible. Some heels run narrow or wide, so look for brands that offer width options or flexible materials. Remember, a well-fitting shoe is the foundation of comfort.
2. Choose the Right Heel Height
I always consider where I’ll be wearing the shoes before picking the heel height. For everyday wear, I prefer something between 2 to 3 inches—stylish but still manageable. For special occasions, I might go higher, but I make sure I can walk confidently in them. Don’t underestimate how heel height affects comfort and posture.
3. Pay Attention to the Heel Type
Stiletto heels look elegant but can be tricky to balance on, especially if you’re not used to them. Block heels or chunky heels offer more stability, which I appreciate for longer wear. Wedges are another comfortable alternative that still look chic. Think about your lifestyle and what heel type suits your needs.
4. Material Matters
I’ve found that leather or faux leather black heels tend to mold to my feet over time and last longer. Suede can be beautiful but requires more care. Also, consider breathability—some synthetic materials might make your feet sweat, which isn’t pleasant for extended wear.
5. Check the Sole and Cushioning
Comfort is key for me, so I always check if the shoes have cushioned insoles or padded footbeds. Rubber soles provide better grip and reduce slipping, which is especially important on smooth surfaces. If the shoes lack cushioning, I sometimes add gel inserts to improve comfort.
6. Style and Versatility
Black high heels are a wardrobe staple, so I look for classic designs that can pair well with multiple outfits—think pointed toes, simple straps, or sleek pumps. Avoid overly trendy details unless you’re buying for a specific look. Versatility ensures you get more use out of your purchase.
7. Budget and Quality Balance
While I don’t mind investing in quality shoes, I also keep my budget in mind. Sometimes mid-range brands offer excellent quality without breaking the bank. Check reviews and ratings to find reliable options. Remember, a good pair of heels is an investment in your style and comfort.
8. Try Them On and Walk Around
If shopping in-store, I always spend time walking around to test the fit and comfort. Even a perfect look can’t compensate for pain or instability. When ordering online, I read return policies carefully and consider ordering multiple sizes if unsure.
Final Thoughts
Finding the perfect pair of black high heel shoes in size 5 is about balancing style, comfort, and practicality. By paying attention to fit, heel height, material, and your personal needs, you can confidently choose shoes that make you look and feel great. I hope my tips help you enjoy the process as much as I have!
Author Profile
-
Anita Baird is the founder and voice behind Shop Into The Night, a blog dedicated to honest, real-world product reviews that help people shop smarter. With a background in product development and user experience, Anita brings years of hands-on industry insight to every review. Whether it’s testing smart lighting, home gadgets, or outdoor gear, she focuses on how products truly perform in everyday life especially when the sun goes down.
Based in Asheville, North Carolina, Anita started the blog in 2025 as a way to cut through marketing fluff and give readers straightforward, tested advice. She believes good products should make life easier, not more complicated. When she’s not writing or testing gear, you’ll likely find her on a quiet trail, curled up with a book under a warm lamp, or fixing a cup of herbal tea while comparing her latest Amazon finds.
Latest entries
- September 12, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested the 39.5 X 20.25 X 7 Inches Sterilite Storage Bin: My Ultimate Solution for Organized Living!
- September 12, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested the Ultimate Bean Bag with a Washable Cover: Here’s Why It’s My New Favorite!
- September 12, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested Ferragamo Women’s 53 mm Black Sunglasses: A Perfect Blend of Style and Comfort!
- September 12, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested the Funniest Physical Therapy Shirts: Here’s What Made Me Laugh and Feel Great!