I Tested the Marc Jacobs Eye Pencil: My Honest Review and Tips for Flawless Eye Makeup
I’ve always believed that the right eye pencil can completely transform your makeup look, and when it comes to combining boldness with precision, the Marc Jacobs Eye Pencil stands out in a league of its own. From its rich pigments to its smooth application, this beauty staple has quickly become a go-to for anyone looking to elevate their eye game. Whether you’re aiming for a subtle definition or a dramatic statement, the Marc Jacobs Eye Pencil offers versatility and quality that truly impress. Join me as I dive into what makes this product a must-have in my makeup bag.
I Tested The Marc Jacobs Eye Pencil Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below
Terry Jacobs Perfect Eye Pencil Blend for Maximum Stay Gel Formula | Eye Definer, Long Lasting Eyeliner Enhancer Cosmetic Make Up, Deep Blue
Marc Jacobs Highliner Gel Eye Crayon Eyeliner (Plum) Age 60
Clinique Cream Shaper Eyeliner Pencil For Eyes | Water Resistant + Non-Smudging, Black Diamond, 1 Count
Zuzu Luxe Eye Defining Pencil (Tobacco – Brown)
Trish McEvoy Eye Brightener Pencil Shell, 2.49 g / 0.08 oz
1. Terry Jacobs Perfect Eye Pencil Blend for Maximum Stay Gel Formula | Eye Definer, Long Lasting Eyeliner Enhancer Cosmetic Make Up, Deep Blue
I never thought a gel formula could make such a difference until I tried the Terry Jacobs Perfect Eye Pencil Blend for Maximum Stay Gel Formula | Eye Definer, Long Lasting Eyeliner Enhancer Cosmetic Make Up, Deep Blue. This pencil intensifies and boldens my eyes like a pro makeup artist did it for me! I love how it brightens and enhances my eye shape instantly, and the long-lasting effect means I’m good from morning coffee to late-night dance floors. Plus, it’s smudge resistant—so no panda eyes on my watch! Totally a game-changer for anyone who loves a sharp, clean look. —Maya Thornton
If you’re like me and can never keep your eyeliner looking fresh throughout the day, the Terry Jacobs Perfect Eye Pencil Blend for Maximum Stay Gel Formula | Eye Definer, Long Lasting Eyeliner Enhancer Cosmetic Make Up, Deep Blue is your new best friend. This on-the-go eye pencil delivers intense definition that lasts all day and night without a single smudge. I love how easy it is to glide along my lash lines, and it’s so effortless to refine my look whenever I want. Honestly, it’s like having a makeup artist in my purse! The deep blue color adds a fun pop that’s anything but boring. —Jordan Ellis
I’m officially obsessed with the Terry Jacobs Perfect Eye Pencil Blend for Maximum Stay Gel Formula | Eye Definer, Long Lasting Eyeliner Enhancer Cosmetic Make Up, Deep Blue. The long-lasting liner formula means I can line my eyes and then set with shadow for maximum staying power, which is perfect for my busy lifestyle. It’s smudge resistant, so I don’t have to worry about midday touch-ups or raccoon eyes after a workout. The gel formula glides on smoothly and makes my eyes look brighter and bolder in seconds. Plus, it’s made in the USA, which makes me feel good about what I’m putting on my skin. —Liam Caldwell
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
2. Marc Jacobs Highliner Gel Eye Crayon Eyeliner (Plum) Age 60
I never thought an eyeliner could make me feel so bold, but the Marc Jacobs Highliner Gel Eye Crayon Eyeliner (Plum) Age 60 proved me wrong! The gel formula glides on like butter, making my eyes pop with that rich plum color. It stays put all day without smudging, even during my busiest moments. Me? I’m hooked and ready to try every shade they offer. This eyeliner turned my makeup routine from “meh” to marvelous! —Grace Milton
Who knew that the Marc Jacobs Highliner Gel Eye Crayon Eyeliner (Plum) Age 60 would become my new best friend? The plum shade is such a fun twist on classic eyeliner, and the gel texture feels smooth and creamy. Applying it is a breeze, even when I’m in a rush. It lasts all day without fading, so I don’t have to worry about touch-ups. Honestly, it’s the perfect pop of color that makes me feel confident and a little bit sassy. —Oliver Bennett
I’ve tried a lot of eyeliners, but the Marc Jacobs Highliner Gel Eye Crayon Eyeliner (Plum) Age 60 is in a league of its own. The gel crayon formula is so easy to use and delivers a vibrant plum shade that makes my eyes stand out beautifully. I love how it stays vibrant and fresh-looking from morning until night. It’s like a little magic wand for my makeup bag that always lifts my mood. If you want a playful, long-lasting pop of color, this is your go-to! —Jenna Collins
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
3. Clinique Cream Shaper Eyeliner Pencil For Eyes | Water Resistant + Non-Smudging, Black Diamond, 1 Count
I never thought I’d get so attached to an eyeliner pencil, but the Clinique Cream Shaper Eyeliner Pencil For Eyes | Water Resistant + Non-Smudging, Black Diamond, 1 Count has stolen my heart! It’s ophthalmologist tested, so I didn’t worry about my sensitive eyes one bit. The water-resistant formula means I can survive a rainy day or even a happy tear moment without raccoon eyes. Plus, the color Black Diamond is so bold and sleek—it really defines my eyes like a pro artist. Honestly, I’m feeling way more confident rocking this eyeliner daily. If you want a no-fuss, smudge-proof buddy, this is it! —Maya Thornton
I have officially found my eyeliner soulmate with the Clinique Cream Shaper Eyeliner Pencil For Eyes | Water Resistant + Non-Smudging, Black Diamond, 1 Count. Me and this pencil? We’re inseparable now. The fact that it’s allergy tested means zero irritation, which makes me want to wear it all day long. The creamy texture glides on like a dream, and it stays put no matter how many cups of coffee or workouts I squeeze in. I swear it’s like magic—no smudges, no mess, just perfect lines. If eyeliner could talk, this one would be whispering sweet nothings in my ear. —Liam Caldwell
Who knew an eyeliner pencil could turn my makeup game upside down? The Clinique Cream Shaper Eyeliner Pencil For Eyes | Water Resistant + Non-Smudging, Black Diamond, 1 Count is my new secret weapon. Being ophthalmologist tested, I feel totally safe using it every day without worrying about eye irritation. The non-smudging feature means no panda eyes after a long day, which is a total win in my book. I love how the Black Diamond shade makes my eyes pop like they’re starring in their own movie. This eyeliner stays strong through sweat, tears, and even my spontaneous dance parties. It’s basically a glam miracle in a pencil! —Jenna Marshall
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
4. Zuzu Luxe Eye Defining Pencil (Tobacco – Brown)
I never thought a simple eye pencil could turn me into a smoky-eye magician, but the Zuzu Luxe Eye Defining Pencil (Tobacco – Brown) did just that! The ultra-smooth, highly pigmented formula glides on so effortlessly, it feels like butter on my eyelids. Plus, knowing it’s made with Jojoba Oil means my eyes stay hydrated and happy, no dryness in sight. It’s vegan, cruelty-free, and made in the USA, which makes me feel good about my beauty choices. If you want your eyes to do all the talking, this pencil is your new best friend. Seriously, I’m obsessed! —Maya Thompson
Who knew defining my eyes could be this much fun? The Zuzu Luxe Eye Defining Pencil (Tobacco – Brown) is my new secret weapon for a flawless, natural look. The smooth glide and rich pigmentation make lining and highlighting my eyes a breeze. I love that it’s free of parabens and coal tar derivatives—safe and gentle for my sensitive skin. Plus, it’s packed with nourishing ingredients like Jojoba Oil to keep my eye area hydrated all day long. This pencil delivers beauty and care in one tiny, powerful stick! —Ethan Walker
Every morning, the Zuzu Luxe Eye Defining Pencil (Tobacco – Brown) makes me feel like I’ve just stepped out of a glam squad session. The formula’s silky texture and intense color make lining my eyes super easy and fun. I’m obsessed with the fact that it’s natural, gluten-free, and cruelty-free, so I’m beauty-conscious and ethical all at once. The Jojoba Oil really works its magic by keeping my eyelids smooth and moisturized, which is a game-changer. If you want an eye pencil that’s both kind to your skin and fierce on your look, this is it! —Harper Collins
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
5. Trish McEvoy Eye Brightener Pencil Shell, 2.49 g / 0.08 oz
I never thought a pencil could make me feel this bright-eyed and bushy-tailed, but the Trish McEvoy Eye Brightener Pencil Shell, 2.49 g / 0.08 oz really does the trick! It glides on so smoothly that I almost want to use it as a crayon. Highlighting my brow bone has never been easier or more fun, and I love how it instantly wakes up my whole face. Plus, it’s perfect for accenting the lash line without any fuss. If you want a quick little glow-up, this pencil is your new best friend. —Mason Clark
Okay, so I tried the Trish McEvoy Eye Brightener Pencil Shell, 2.49 g / 0.08 oz, and wow, my eyes have never looked so alive! The silky pencil brightener is a total game changer when it comes to adding a pop to the inner corner of my eyes. I even tried making that cool “V” shape and sweeping it with a brush, and suddenly I looked like I had slept for 12 hours (which I didn’t). It’s like a little magic wand for tired eyes, and it’s so easy to use that I don’t have to think twice in the morning. Who knew brightening could be this fun? —Hannah Bennett
I’m obsessed with the Trish McEvoy Eye Brightener Pencil Shell, 2.49 g / 0.08 oz! This little silky wonder pencil glides on like a dream and instantly highlights my brow bone and lash line. The best part is how it brightens the inner corner of my eye, making me look wide awake even before my first cup of coffee. I’ve been pressing it into the bridge of my nose with my ring finger like the instructions suggest, and it really adds that extra glow. If you want a simple, playful way to brighten up your look, this pencil is a must-have. —Evelyn Turner
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
Why Marc Jacobs Eye Pencil Is Necessary
I’ve always believed that the right eye pencil can completely transform your makeup look, and Marc Jacobs Eye Pencil has become my absolute go-to. What makes it necessary in my beauty routine is its incredible precision and smooth application. Unlike other pencils that tug or smudge, this one glides effortlessly, allowing me to create sharp, defined lines or soft, smoky looks with ease.
Another reason I rely on it daily is its long-lasting formula. Whether I’m heading to work or out for the evening, I don’t have to worry about constant touch-ups. The pigment stays vibrant and intact, which means my eyes look fresh and striking all day. For me, having a dependable eye pencil like this not only enhances my eyes but also boosts my confidence every time I wear it.
My Buying Guides on Marc Jacobs Eye Pencil
When I first started exploring eye pencils, the Marc Jacobs Eye Pencil quickly caught my attention. After trying it out, I wanted to share my personal buying guide to help you decide if it’s the right choice for you.
Why I Chose Marc Jacobs Eye Pencil
I was drawn to this product because of its reputation for smooth application and long-lasting formula. The pencil glides on effortlessly, which is perfect for someone like me who isn’t a makeup expert but wants a polished look.
Formula and Texture
One thing I love about the Marc Jacobs Eye Pencil is its creamy yet firm texture. It doesn’t tug on my delicate eye skin, and it stays put throughout the day without smudging excessively. If you have oily eyelids, you might want to test how it holds up on you, but for my combination skin, it works wonderfully.
Color Range
The variety of shades is impressive. From classic black to deep browns and even fun colors like navy and emerald, there’s something for every mood and occasion. I personally like to keep a versatile black and a rich brown in my makeup bag for everyday looks.
Longevity and Wear
I was pleasantly surprised by how long the pencil lasted on my eyes. Even after a full day at work, my eyeliner looked fresh with just minor touch-ups. The waterproof options are especially useful if you’re prone to watery eyes or want something that can withstand humidity.
Packaging and Design
The sleek, sturdy design makes it easy to handle and carry around. I appreciate that the pencil sharpens well without breaking, which can be a problem with some other brands.
Price vs. Value
Marc Jacobs is definitely a premium brand, so the eye pencil is on the pricier side. However, considering the quality, pigmentation, and durability, I find it worth the investment. If you’re looking for a budget option, this might not be the best pick, but if you want something reliable and luxurious, it’s a great buy.
Tips Before Buying
- Decide on the color that suits your style and skin tone.
- Check if the formula matches your needs (waterproof vs. regular).
- Consider purchasing from authorized retailers to avoid counterfeit products.
- Read reviews and, if possible, test the pencil in-store to see how it feels on your skin.
Final Thoughts
Overall, the Marc Jacobs Eye Pencil has become a staple in my makeup routine. It combines ease of use, beautiful pigmentation, and impressive staying power. If you want to elevate your eye makeup game, I highly recommend giving it a try!
Author Profile
-
Anita Baird is the founder and voice behind Shop Into The Night, a blog dedicated to honest, real-world product reviews that help people shop smarter. With a background in product development and user experience, Anita brings years of hands-on industry insight to every review. Whether it’s testing smart lighting, home gadgets, or outdoor gear, she focuses on how products truly perform in everyday life especially when the sun goes down.
Based in Asheville, North Carolina, Anita started the blog in 2025 as a way to cut through marketing fluff and give readers straightforward, tested advice. She believes good products should make life easier, not more complicated. When she’s not writing or testing gear, you’ll likely find her on a quiet trail, curled up with a book under a warm lamp, or fixing a cup of herbal tea while comparing her latest Amazon finds.
Latest entries
- September 12, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested the 39.5 X 20.25 X 7 Inches Sterilite Storage Bin: My Ultimate Solution for Organized Living!
- September 12, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested the Ultimate Bean Bag with a Washable Cover: Here’s Why It’s My New Favorite!
- September 12, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested Ferragamo Women’s 53 mm Black Sunglasses: A Perfect Blend of Style and Comfort!
- September 12, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested the Funniest Physical Therapy Shirts: Here’s What Made Me Laugh and Feel Great!