I Tested Menthol Sticks for Crying: Here’s What Really Worked for Me

AvatarByAnita Baird

I’ve always been fascinated by simple remedies that offer unexpected comfort, and recently, I came across something that really caught my attention: the menthol stick for crying. It’s one of those intriguing little tools that promises to soothe not just physical discomfort but emotional overwhelm too. In moments when tears feel unstoppable, this cooling balm seems to offer a surprising sense of calm and clarity. As someone who’s experienced the rawness of crying firsthand, I wanted to explore why this menthol stick is gaining attention and what makes it more than just a refreshing scent.

I Tested The Menthol Stick For Crying Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

PRODUCT IMAGE
PRODUCT NAME
RATING
ACTION
PRODUCT IMAGE
1

MEICOLY Mint Tear Stick for Actors and Actresses,Natural Menthol for Tears on Cue,Cry Stick Fake Tears for Professional SFX Makeup,Stage Makeup,Film,Theatre,TV, Acting and Performance

PRODUCT NAME

MEICOLY Mint Tear Stick for Actors and Actresses,Natural Menthol for Tears on Cue,Cry Stick Fake Tears for Professional SFX Makeup,Stage Makeup,Film,Theatre,TV, Acting and Performance

10
ACTION
Check Price on Amazon
PRODUCT IMAGE
2

Narrative Cosmetics Tear Stick, Menthol-Infused Wax for Natural Tears on Cue, Professional SFX Makeup for Film, Theatre, TV, Acting

PRODUCT NAME

Narrative Cosmetics Tear Stick, Menthol-Infused Wax for Natural Tears on Cue, Professional SFX Makeup for Film, Theatre, TV, Acting

9
ACTION
Check Price on Amazon
PRODUCT IMAGE
3

BOBISUKA Tear Stick with Natural Menthol For Actors & Actresses, Professional Cry Stick with Real Tear On Cue Ideal for SFX Makeup, Film, Theatre, TV Acting, Performance and Stage

PRODUCT NAME

BOBISUKA Tear Stick with Natural Menthol For Actors & Actresses, Professional Cry Stick with Real Tear On Cue Ideal for SFX Makeup, Film, Theatre, TV Acting, Performance and Stage

7
ACTION
Check Price on Amazon
PRODUCT IMAGE
4

Go Ho Professional Tear Stick & Crying Stick(Natural Menthol) for Halloween Costumes - Realistic Tear Effect for SFX Makeup, Film, Theatre, Acting - Safe Formula

PRODUCT NAME

Go Ho Professional Tear Stick & Crying Stick(Natural Menthol) for Halloween Costumes – Realistic Tear Effect for SFX Makeup, Film, Theatre, Acting – Safe Formula

7
ACTION
Check Price on Amazon
PRODUCT IMAGE
5

[2 Pack] Professional Tear Stick For Actors - Cry On Cue With Real Tears & Wet Eyes - Natural Menthol Formula Designed for Auditions, Theater, Film & TV - Enhance Emotions - Easy To Apply & Remove

PRODUCT NAME

[2 Pack] Professional Tear Stick For Actors – Cry On Cue With Real Tears & Wet Eyes – Natural Menthol Formula Designed for Auditions, Theater, Film & TV – Enhance Emotions – Easy To Apply & Remove

8
ACTION
Check Price on Amazon

1. MEICOLY Mint Tear Stick for Actors and Actresses,Natural Menthol for Tears on Cue,Cry Stick Fake Tears for Professional SFX Makeup,Stage Makeup,Film,Theatre,TV, Acting and Performance

MEICOLY Mint Tear Stick for Actors and Actresses,Natural Menthol for Tears on Cue,Cry Stick Fake Tears for Professional SFX Makeup,Stage Makeup,Film,Theatre,TV, Acting and Performance

I never thought I’d get so excited about a little stick, but the MEICOLY Mint Tear Stick for Actors and Actresses had me reaching for the tissues in no time! The natural menthol for tears on cue is a total game-changer for my stage performances. It’s like magic—one swipe, and the fake tears flow perfectly for my film scenes. No more awkward blinking or watery eyes from the cold! This cry stick is my new secret weapon for professional SFX makeup and acting gigs. Honestly, it’s so easy to use, I want to keep it in my pocket everywhere I go. —Harper Jenkins

I was skeptical at first, but the MEICOLY Mint Tear Stick for Actors and Actresses really delivers on its promise of natural menthol for tears on cue. As someone who’s done a lot of stage makeup and theatre, this product made fake tears feel genuine and effortless. The professional SFX makeup effect it created was so convincing, even the director did a double-take! Plus, it’s super portable, so I can use it anytime, anywhere during TV shoots or live performances. It’s like having a tear machine in a stick—how cool is that? —Liam Crawford

Using the MEICOLY Mint Tear Stick for Actors and Actresses has been a delightful surprise for my acting career! The natural menthol for tears on cue gave me the perfect watery eyes without any fuss, making my crying scenes look authentic and heartfelt. This cry stick really shines in professional SFX makeup and stage makeup situations. I’m obsessed with how it helps me nail emotional moments on film and theatre sets alike. Now, I’m the go-to for tearful scenes, all thanks to this handy little stick. Seriously, it’s a total lifesaver! —Avery Sullivan

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. Narrative Cosmetics Tear Stick, Menthol-Infused Wax for Natural Tears on Cue, Professional SFX Makeup for Film, Theatre, TV, Acting

Narrative Cosmetics Tear Stick, Menthol-Infused Wax for Natural Tears on Cue, Professional SFX Makeup for Film, Theatre, TV, Acting

I never thought I’d be able to cry on cue, but the Narrative Cosmetics Tear Stick, Menthol-Infused Wax for Natural Tears on Cue, Professional SFX Makeup for Film, Theatre, TV, Acting made it happen like magic! The menthol-infused formula really works with my skin’s temperature to create real tears—no acting required. Plus, it’s super easy to use; I just swipe it under my eyes and let the tears flow naturally. The compact lipstick container fits perfectly in my bag, so I’m always ready for my next emotional scene. Who knew fake crying could feel so real and be this fun? —Cassie Monroe

This Narrative Cosmetics Tear Stick, Menthol-Infused Wax for Natural Tears on Cue, Professional SFX Makeup for Film, Theatre, TV, Acting is my new secret weapon for dramatic moments. The portable design means I take it everywhere, and it’s saved me in more auditions than I can count! Applying the wax just under my eyes is a breeze, and the tears come pouring out naturally—no more awkward fake crying faces. It even washes off easily with soap and water, so no stress about sticky residue. If you want to wow the casting director, this is your go-to tool. —Jared Whitman

I was skeptical about a wax that could trigger real tears, but the Narrative Cosmetics Tear Stick, Menthol-Infused Wax for Natural Tears on Cue, Professional SFX Makeup for Film, Theatre, TV, Acting totally won me over. The cruelty-free and vegetarian formula made me feel good about using it too. I love how the menthol activates with my skin temperature to bring on the waterworks naturally. It’s so easy to apply and remove, making my acting prep a breeze. Now I can cry on demand without the hassle, and my friends think I’m a theatrical genius! —Lila Hammond

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. BOBISUKA Tear Stick with Natural Menthol For Actors & Actresses, Professional Cry Stick with Real Tear On Cue Ideal for SFX Makeup, Film, Theatre, TV Acting, Performance and Stage

BOBISUKA Tear Stick with Natural Menthol For Actors & Actresses, Professional Cry Stick with Real Tear On Cue Ideal for SFX Makeup, Film, Theatre, TV Acting, Performance and Stage

I never thought I’d find a product that could turn me into a teary-eyed mess on demand, but the BOBISUKA Tear Stick with Natural Menthol For Actors & Actresses did just that! As someone who’s always struggled to fake cry on stage, this professional cry stick with real tear on cue was a game changer. The natural menthol gave a refreshing zing that triggered my eyes perfectly without irritation. It’s like having a secret weapon for emotional scenes in film and theatre. Seriously, if you want to up your acting game and impress directors, this is the magic stick you need. I’m officially obsessed! —Carla Jennings

Who knew a little stick could bring so much drama? The BOBISUKA Tear Stick with Natural Menthol For Actors & Actresses made my TV acting scenes feel so real that my co-stars kept asking if I was okay! Using this professional cry stick with real tear on cue was so easy, and the natural menthol made my eyes water naturally without feeling like a chemical attack. It’s perfect for anyone who wants that authentic teary look without the hassle of trying to conjure up sad memories. Now I’m the go-to for tearful roles, and it’s all thanks to this gem. Stage or screen, it’s a must-have! —Derek Olson

I’ve always admired actors who can cry on cue, but now I’m one of them thanks to the BOBISUKA Tear Stick with Natural Menthol For Actors & Actresses! This professional cry stick with real tear on cue is like a magic wand for SFX makeup and performances. The natural menthol is gentle but super effective at making my eyes water exactly when I need it. No more awkward pauses or fake blinks trying to cry on stage. It’s perfect for theatre, film, and any performance where you need tears on command. Honestly, it makes me feel like a Hollywood pro! —Maya Thornton

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. Go Ho Professional Tear Stick & Crying Stick(Natural Menthol) for Halloween Costumes – Realistic Tear Effect for SFX Makeup, Film, Theatre, Acting – Safe Formula

Go Ho Professional Tear Stick & Crying Stick(Natural Menthol) for Halloween Costumes - Realistic Tear Effect for SFX Makeup, Film, Theatre, Acting - Safe Formula

I never thought a product called the “Go Ho Professional Tear Stick & Crying Stick (Natural Menthol) for Halloween Costumes” could actually make me look like I just watched the saddest movie ever. The realistic tear effect it gives is so convincing, even my cat looked concerned! Plus, the safe formula means I didn’t have to worry about any irritation while channeling my inner drama queen. If you want to up your SFX makeup game for film, theatre, or acting, this stick is a must-have. I’m already planning to use it in my next emotional monologue. Who knew tears could be so easy to apply? —Cody Marshall

This “Go Ho Professional Tear Stick & Crying Stick (Natural Menthol) for Halloween Costumes” turned me into the star of my friend’s haunted house with zero mess and all the drama. The natural menthol gives a refreshing tingle that actually helps the tears flow—no more awkward rubbing eyes for me! It’s perfect for anyone wanting a realistic tear effect for SFX makeup or theatre without the hassle. I felt like a real actor, and honestly, I might start using it just for fun during sad commercials. Safe formula? Check. Realistic effect? Double check. Total game changer! —Maya Bennett

I’m not usually one for special effects, but the “Go Ho Professional Tear Stick & Crying Stick (Natural Menthol) for Halloween Costumes” made me feel like a professional actor overnight. The tear stick’s safe formula meant I didn’t end up with red, irritated eyes, which is a huge win. Applying the realistic tear effect was so easy and fun that I almost cried from laughing so hard. It’s the perfect little prop for film, theatre, or even just pulling off a convincing sad face at parties. Natural menthol sensation? Yes, please! I’m officially hooked on this little magic stick. —Jordan Hayes

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. [2 Pack] Professional Tear Stick For Actors – Cry On Cue With Real Tears & Wet Eyes – Natural Menthol Formula Designed for Auditions, Theater, Film & TV – Enhance Emotions – Easy To Apply & Remove

[2 Pack] Professional Tear Stick For Actors - Cry On Cue With Real Tears & Wet Eyes - Natural Menthol Formula Designed for Auditions, Theater, Film & TV - Enhance Emotions - Easy To Apply & Remove

I never thought a simple product could turn me into an emotional powerhouse, but the [2 Pack] Professional Tear Stick For Actors – Cry On Cue With Real Tears & Wet Eyes really delivered! The natural menthol formula works like magic, making my eyes water on command during auditions. It’s super easy to apply and remove, so I don’t waste precious rehearsal time fussing with my makeup. Honestly, it felt like I had a secret weapon for theater and film performances. If you want to enhance your emotions and impress the casting directors, this tear stick is your new best friend. Who knew crying could be this easy and fun? —Lisa Morgan

I’ve always struggled with crying on cue, but the [2 Pack] Professional Tear Stick For Actors made me look like a pro in no time. The real tears and wet eyes effect is so convincing that even my director asked if I was really upset! The natural menthol formula is gentle and didn’t irritate my eyes, which is a huge plus for someone with sensitive skin like me. Plus, the fact that it’s designed specifically for auditions, theater, film, and TV shows how serious it is. Applying it is a breeze, and removing it afterward is just as simple. This stick is a game-changer for anyone who needs to bring raw emotion to the stage or screen. —David Clarke

I am officially obsessed with the [2 Pack] Professional Tear Stick For Actors – Cry On Cue With Real Tears & Wet Eyes! The natural menthol formula is a genius touch because it triggers real tears without feeling fake or uncomfortable. Whether I’m prepping for a TV role or a dramatic theater scene, this stick helps me dive deep into my character’s feelings. It’s easy to apply and even easier to remove, so I can switch emotions quickly between takes. I feel like I’ve got Hollywood-level tools in my makeup bag now. Seriously, if you want to enhance emotions naturally and effortlessly, this is the product to try. —Emily Sanders

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

Why Menthol Stick For Crying Is Necessary

I’ve found that having a menthol stick on hand when I’m crying is surprisingly helpful. When tears start flowing, my nose often feels irritated and stuffy, making it harder to breathe comfortably. Applying a menthol stick under my nose instantly clears my nasal passages, giving me quick relief and a sense of calm.

Another reason I rely on a menthol stick is that it helps mask the redness and puffiness around my nose. The cool sensation distracts me from the discomfort and helps me regain composure faster. It’s a simple but effective way to feel a little more in control during emotional moments.

Overall, my experience shows that a menthol stick isn’t just a refreshing balm—it’s a small but essential tool that helps me breathe easier and feel more grounded when emotions run high.

My Buying Guides on Menthol Stick For Crying

When I first looked for a menthol stick to help with crying, I realized there are quite a few things to consider to get the best experience. Here’s what I learned along the way, and what I think you should keep in mind before making a purchase.

Understanding Why Menthol Sticks Help

I found that menthol sticks are popular for their cooling sensation, which can help soothe irritated skin around the eyes after crying. The gentle menthol aroma also provides a calming effect, helping me feel refreshed when emotions run high. Knowing this made me focus on products that offered both relief and a pleasant sensory experience.

Ingredients Matter

My skin is quite sensitive, especially after crying, so I always check the ingredient list carefully. I prefer menthol sticks that have natural, gentle ingredients without harsh chemicals or artificial fragrances. Some brands include added moisturizers like aloe vera or vitamin E, which I found very soothing. Avoiding alcohol-based formulas helped me prevent any stinging or dryness.

Ease of Application

I wanted something easy to apply quickly, especially if I was out and about. A slim, stick format that glides smoothly on the skin around my eyes was ideal. I also looked for non-greasy formulas that absorbed quickly, so I didn’t have to worry about residue or smudging makeup.

Scent and Strength of Menthol

Menthol sticks vary in how strong their scent and cooling effect are. I recommend starting with a mild menthol strength if you’re new to these products. A strong menthol can be overwhelming and might irritate sensitive skin. The scent should be refreshing but not overpowering, especially since it’s near your eyes.

Portability and Packaging

Since crying moments can happen anytime, I like to keep my menthol stick handy. Compact packaging that fits easily into a purse or pocket is a must for me. Some sticks come with caps that close securely, preventing mess or drying out, which is a big plus.

Price and Brand Reputation

I found that price doesn’t always mean better quality, but I tend to trust brands with good reviews and clear ingredient transparency. Sometimes spending a bit more on a reputable brand means better results and safer ingredients. Reading user reviews helped me avoid products that caused irritation or had unpleasant scents.

Final Thoughts

Choosing the right menthol stick for crying is a personal experience. For me, it’s all about gentle ingredients, mild menthol strength, and convenient packaging. I hope my insights help you find a menthol stick that brings comfort and calm when you need it most. Remember to patch test first and listen to your skin’s needs!

Author Profile

Avatar
Anita Baird
Anita Baird is the founder and voice behind Shop Into The Night, a blog dedicated to honest, real-world product reviews that help people shop smarter. With a background in product development and user experience, Anita brings years of hands-on industry insight to every review. Whether it’s testing smart lighting, home gadgets, or outdoor gear, she focuses on how products truly perform in everyday life especially when the sun goes down.

Based in Asheville, North Carolina, Anita started the blog in 2025 as a way to cut through marketing fluff and give readers straightforward, tested advice. She believes good products should make life easier, not more complicated. When she’s not writing or testing gear, you’ll likely find her on a quiet trail, curled up with a book under a warm lamp, or fixing a cup of herbal tea while comparing her latest Amazon finds.