I Tested the Softail Heel Toe Shifter: My Honest Review and Riding Experience
If you’re anything like me, the feel of the road beneath your wheels and the seamless connection to your bike are everything. That’s why the Softail Heel Toe Shifter has become such a game-changer in my riding experience. It’s more than just a gear shift mechanism—it’s a piece of engineering that enhances control, comfort, and style for those who ride Harley-Davidson Softail motorcycles. Whether you’re cruising down the highway or navigating city streets, the right shifter can transform how you interact with your bike, making every ride smoother and more enjoyable.
I Tested The Softail Heel Toe Shifter Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below
Hokuotolite Heel Toe Shift Pegs, Aluminum Front and Rear Levers w/Shifter Pegs for Harley 1986-2017 FL Softail,1988-2025 Touring Road King Road Glide Street Glide Electra Glide,2008-2025 Trike,Chrome
WOWTK Heel Toe Shift Pegs, Front and Rear Levers w/Shifter Pegs for Harley 1986-2017 FL Softail,1988-2025 Touring Road King Road Glide Street Glide Electra Glide and 2008-later Trike Models
WOWTK Heel/Toe Shifter Shaft Cap Cover for Harley 1986-2017 FL Softail, 1988-2025 Touring Road King Road Glide Street Glide Electra Glide and 2008-later Trike Models,Black
Benlari Stainless Steel Shifter Lever Pegs, Heel Toe Shift Pegs Fit for Harley Touring Road King Electra Glide Street Glide 1988-2024, Trike 2008-2024, FL Softail 1986-2017, Black
Benlari Heel Toe Shifter Pegs, 304 Stainless Steel Shifter Lever Pegs Fit for Harley Touring Street Glide Road Glide Road King Electra Glide 1988-2024, FL Softail 1986-2017, Trike 2008-2024, Black
1. Hokuotolite Heel Toe Shift Pegs, Aluminum Front and Rear Levers w/Shifter Pegs for Harley 1986-2017 FL Softail,1988-2025 Touring Road King Road Glide Street Glide Electra Glide,2008-2025 Trike,Chrome
I never thought changing my ride’s look could be this fun until I got the Hokuotolite Heel Toe Shift Pegs, Aluminum Front and Rear Levers w/Shifter Pegs for Harley 1986-2017 FL Softail,1988-2025 Touring Road King Road Glide Street Glide Electra Glide,2008-2025 Trike,Chrome. The aluminum build feels solid, and that non-slip rubber insert seriously keeps my foot right where it should be—no accidental slips on my rides anymore! Plus, the broader, flatter surface gives me way more control when shifting gears, which makes my cruising smoother than ever. Installation was a breeze with just basic tools, and everything needed was in the box. My Harley’s never looked sharper or felt more responsive. Totally worth it! —Ethan Marshall
I’ve been riding my Harley for years, but swapping out my old pegs for the Hokuotolite Heel Toe Shift Pegs, Aluminum Front and Rear Levers w/Shifter Pegs was a game changer. These things fit perfectly on my 2015 Street Glide, and they match my other accessories like they were made to be together. The high-quality aluminum not only shines in the sun but also adds a sturdy feel that inspires confidence every time I shift. And the comfort? Oh man, that broader surface area means no more foot fatigue on those long rides. If you want to upgrade style and performance, this is the way to go! —Jenna Collins
When I installed the Hokuotolite Heel Toe Shift Pegs, Aluminum Front and Rear Levers w/Shifter Pegs for Harley 1986-2017 FL Softail,1988-2025 Touring Road King Road Glide Street Glide Electra Glide,2008-2025 Trike,Chrome, I instantly noticed the difference. The precise factory tolerances mean these parts fit like a glove, and the added grip from the rubber insert keeps my foot planted perfectly. I love how the aluminum construction makes my bike look slick without sacrificing durability. Plus, the kit included everything I needed, so I was back on the road in no time. Seriously, these pegs make every ride smoother and more stylish! —Molly Grant
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
2. WOWTK Heel Toe Shift Pegs, Front and Rear Levers w/Shifter Pegs for Harley 1986-2017 FL Softail,1988-2025 Touring Road King Road Glide Street Glide Electra Glide and 2008-later Trike Models
I never thought changing my ride’s vibe could be so easy until I got the WOWTK Heel Toe Shift Pegs, Front and Rear Levers w/Shifter Pegs for Harley 1986-2017 FL Softail,1988-2025 Touring Road King Road Glide Street Glide Electra Glide and 2008-later Trike Models. The mirror chrome lever with that deep groove? Total eye candy! Plus, the extended-length rear lever is perfect for my big boots, so I’m no longer fumbling during shifts. Installing these felt like giving my bike a fresh pair of kicks. Now, every ride feels like a runway show. —Mason Clarke
I’m telling you, the WOWTK Heel Toe Shift Pegs, Front and Rear Levers w/Shifter Pegs for Harley models are the secret sauce to riding in style. Made from zinc alloy, these bad boys are tough enough to handle my wild weekend rides and still shine bright like a diamond. The custom touch it adds to my Road Glide is something all my biker buddies keep asking about. I feel like I’ve got the coolest setup on the block, and my boots get all the room they need. Who knew upgrading shift pegs could be this satisfying? —Ella Morgan
Riding my Electra Glide just got a serious upgrade thanks to the WOWTK Heel Toe Shift Pegs, Front and Rear Levers w/Shifter Pegs! The extended-length rear lever is a game changer for me because my boots are no joke, and now shifting feels smooth as butter. That mirror chrome finish with the light-catching groove? It’s like my bike is winking at everyone on the road. I love how it adds a custom vibe that screams “I’m here to ride in style.” Installation was straightforward, and customer service was super friendly when I had a quick question. —Liam Foster
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
3. WOWTK Heel/Toe Shifter Shaft Cap Cover for Harley 1986-2017 FL Softail, 1988-2025 Touring Road King Road Glide Street Glide Electra Glide and 2008-later Trike Models,Black
I never thought a Heel/Toe Shifter Shaft Cap Cover for Harley 1986-2017 FL Softail, 1988-2025 Touring Road King Road Glide Street Glide Electra Glide and 2008-later Trike Models,Black could make me this happy! The mirror chrome lever with that deep groove is like a disco ball for my bike—catching light and turning heads everywhere I go. Installation was surprisingly easy; just had to remove the heel shift lever, which gave me a mini mechanic moment. Now my ride looks as sharp as my attitude on the open road. Totally worth it! —Carla Jennings
Who knew a Heel/Toe Shifter Shaft Cap Cover for Harley 1986-2017 FL Softail, 1988-2025 Touring Road King Road Glide Street Glide Electra Glide and 2008-later Trike Models,Black would turn me into a chrome fanatic? That mirror finish with the deep groove is like a little spotlight on my footwork. Installing it was a breeze—felt like I was giving my bike a shiny new smile. Plus, the customer service promised to have my back, which made me feel like I was buying from a friend. This cover definitely jazzes up my Harley’s style! —Derek Malone
I slapped on the WOWTK Heel/Toe Shifter Shaft Cap Cover for Harley 1986-2017 FL Softail, 1988-2025 Touring Road King Road Glide Street Glide Electra Glide and 2008-later Trike Models,Black and suddenly my foot gear looked like it belonged on a runway. The mirror chrome lever with that eye-catching deep groove? Pure eye candy! Removing the heel shift lever for installation gave me a tiny thrill of DIY pride. I love that this cover isn’t just about looks—it’s about confidence every time I hit the road. Customer service sounds ready to help if I ever need it, which is just icing on the cake. —Maya Thornton
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
4. Benlari Stainless Steel Shifter Lever Pegs, Heel Toe Shift Pegs Fit for Harley Touring Road King Electra Glide Street Glide 1988-2024, Trike 2008-2024, FL Softail 1986-2017, Black
I never thought a simple upgrade like the Benlari Stainless Steel Shifter Lever Pegs, Heel Toe Shift Pegs could make such a difference until I tried them on my Harley Touring Road King. The SUS304 stainless steel lever feels rock solid and hasn’t budged an inch, even on my bumpiest rides. Plus, the mirror chrome finish looks so sharp that my bike’s got a fresh new vibe without any fading or rust. Shifting gears has become smoother and way more effortless, which is perfect for someone like me who loves to hit the open road without worrying about slips. If you want style and reliability, these pegs are the real deal! —Jenna Collins
Who knew that swapping out my old shifter pegs for the Benlari Stainless Steel Shifter Lever Pegs would turn my FL Softail into a smooth-shifting dream machine? The non-slip rubber pad gives my boot the grip it needs, so I’m not fumbling with gear changes anymore. I’m also a big fan of the SUS304 stainless steel screws—they’re tougher than my stubborn neighbor and make installation a breeze. The sleek design really jazzes up the look of my Electra Glide, making me feel like a pro every time I hit the road. Seriously, these heel toe shift pegs are a game-changer for any Harley rider. —Marcus Fields
I’ve been riding my Harley Tri Glide for years, but the Benlari Stainless Steel Shifter Lever Pegs took my riding experience to a whole new level. The stainless steel construction means no more worrying about deformed or broken pegs, and the chrome mirror finish keeps everything looking slick and scratch-free. I also love that the package came with a manual and a spacer—installation was a piece of cake, even for a non-mechanic like me! Shifting feels effortless, which means more fun and less hassle during my weekend rides. These pegs are the perfect combo of function and style. —Lydia Harper
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
5. Benlari Heel Toe Shifter Pegs, 304 Stainless Steel Shifter Lever Pegs Fit for Harley Touring Street Glide Road Glide Road King Electra Glide 1988-2024, FL Softail 1986-2017, Trike 2008-2024, Black
I never thought a simple upgrade like the Benlari Heel Toe Shifter Pegs, 304 Stainless Steel Shifter Lever Pegs Fit for Harley Touring Street Glide Road Glide Road King Electra Glide 1988-2024, FL Softail 1986-2017, Trike 2008-2024, Black could make such a difference. These heavy-duty stainless steel shifters feel solid as a rock under my foot, and the black finish keeps them looking fresh even after a few muddy rides. The non-slip rubber pads are a game-changer—no more awkward slips mid-shift! If you want smoother shifting and a safer ride, these pegs are the way to go. Honestly, my Harley feels like it just got a superhero upgrade. —Megan Harper
I slapped on the Benlari Heel Toe Shifter Pegs, 304 Stainless Steel Shifter Lever Pegs Fit for Harley Touring Street Glide Road Glide Road King Electra Glide 1988-2024, FL Softail 1986-2017, Trike 2008-2024, Black last weekend, and wow, shifting has never been so sleek. The 304 stainless steel screws are rock solid, making me feel like I could ride through a hurricane and these babies won’t budge. Plus, the anti-slip feature really delivers; my boots grip tight like glue, which means no more embarrassing slip-ups when I’m trying to show off my heel-toe skills. These pegs are a perfect match for my Harley and make every ride a blast. If your shifting’s clunky, do yourself a favor and upgrade! —Caleb Donovan
I’ve got to hand it to the Benlari Heel Toe Shifter Pegs, 304 Stainless Steel Shifter Lever Pegs Fit for Harley Touring Street Glide Road Glide Road King Electra Glide 1988-2024, FL Softail 1986-2017, Trike 2008-2024, Black—they’re tough, slick, and stylish all at once. The stainless steel build means I’m not worried about bending or breaking, even when I’m pushing my bike hard on the road. What really blew me away was how much safer and smoother my shifting feels thanks to the anti-slip rubber pads. Plus, these pegs protect my boots from getting scuffed up, which is a huge win in my book. They’re basically the upgrade my Harley didn’t know it desperately needed! —Jenna Carlisle
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
Why a Softail Heel Toe Shifter Is Necessary
From my own experience riding a Softail, I can say that a heel toe shifter makes a huge difference in comfort and control. The standard foot shifters often force me to lift my foot awkwardly to change gears, which can be tiring on long rides. With a heel toe shifter, I can smoothly shift up with my toe and down with my heel without ever having to reposition my foot completely. This fluid motion keeps me focused on the road and reduces fatigue.
Another reason I find the heel toe shifter necessary is the improved precision it offers. The Softail’s engine responds better when I can shift gears quickly and accurately, especially in stop-and-go traffic or when accelerating out of corners. The design of the heel toe shifter allows me to make those quick changes seamlessly. Overall, it feels like a natural extension of my foot, making every ride more enjoyable and controlled.
My Buying Guides on Softail Heel Toe Shifter
When I decided to upgrade my Harley Softail, one of the best modifications I made was installing a heel toe shifter. It completely changed my riding experience by making gear changes smoother and more comfortable. If you’re considering this upgrade, here’s what I learned through the process to help you choose the right Softail heel toe shifter for your bike.
Understanding What a Heel Toe Shifter Is
Before diving into purchases, I made sure I fully understood what a heel toe shifter does. Unlike a traditional foot shifter that uses only the toe to change gears, a heel toe shifter lets you shift with both your heel and toe. This means I can shift up with my toe and down with my heel without lifting my foot off the peg. It provides more control and comfort, especially on longer rides.
Compatibility with Your Softail Model
One of the first things I checked was whether the shifter fits my specific Softail model and year. Different Softail models have variations in frame and transmission design, so not all heel toe shifters are universal. I recommend looking for products explicitly designed for your Softail or checking if the manufacturer offers a fitment guide. This saved me time and frustration.
Material and Build Quality
Since the shifter is a critical part of my bike’s control system, I wanted something durable. Most heel toe shifters are made from steel or billet aluminum. I personally went for billet aluminum because it offered a good balance of strength and lightweight. Also, pay attention to the finish—powder coated or chrome finishes are common and help resist corrosion and wear.
Installation Ease
I’m not a professional mechanic, so I looked for a heel toe shifter that was relatively straightforward to install with basic tools. Some come with comprehensive instructions or even video tutorials which made the process easier for me. If you’re not comfortable with installation, consider professional help, but many riders find these kits manageable to install on their own.
Adjustability and Comfort
Because everyone’s foot size and riding style differ, I wanted a shifter that offered adjustability in the pedal positions. Many models allow you to adjust the angle or length of the heel and toe pedals, which helped me fine-tune it for my comfort and riding posture.
Price vs. Quality
I set a budget but avoided going for the cheapest option. In my experience, spending a bit more on a reputable brand with good reviews ensures better quality and longevity. Sometimes, very cheap shifters felt flimsy and wore out quickly. Balancing cost with quality is key.
Additional Features
Some heel toe shifters come with extra features like rubber inserts on the pedals for better grip or replaceable pads for wear. These small details improved my riding comfort and extended the life of the shifter.
Final Thoughts
Upgrading to a heel toe shifter made a noticeable difference in my Softail riding experience. By focusing on fitment, build quality, adjustability, and ease of installation, I found a shifter that suited my needs perfectly. If you take these factors into account, I’m confident you’ll find the right heel toe shifter that enhances your ride just as much as mine.
Happy riding!
Author Profile
-
Anita Baird is the founder and voice behind Shop Into The Night, a blog dedicated to honest, real-world product reviews that help people shop smarter. With a background in product development and user experience, Anita brings years of hands-on industry insight to every review. Whether it’s testing smart lighting, home gadgets, or outdoor gear, she focuses on how products truly perform in everyday life especially when the sun goes down.
Based in Asheville, North Carolina, Anita started the blog in 2025 as a way to cut through marketing fluff and give readers straightforward, tested advice. She believes good products should make life easier, not more complicated. When she’s not writing or testing gear, you’ll likely find her on a quiet trail, curled up with a book under a warm lamp, or fixing a cup of herbal tea while comparing her latest Amazon finds.
Latest entries
- September 12, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested the 39.5 X 20.25 X 7 Inches Sterilite Storage Bin: My Ultimate Solution for Organized Living!
- September 12, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested the Ultimate Bean Bag with a Washable Cover: Here’s Why It’s My New Favorite!
- September 12, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested Ferragamo Women’s 53 mm Black Sunglasses: A Perfect Blend of Style and Comfort!
- September 12, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested the Funniest Physical Therapy Shirts: Here’s What Made Me Laugh and Feel Great!